SARS-CoV-2 spike protein fusion transformation: Difference between revisions
Eric Martz (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
(31 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
SARS-CoV-2 spike protein undergoes a dramatic conformational rearrangement (<scene name='85/857791/Morf-6xr8-6xra-lin-theis-cao/5'>restore initial scene</scene>) that plays a central role in fusing the coronavirus membrane with the host cell membrane<ref name="cai-zhang">PMID: 32694201</ref>. Similar conformational transformations have been observed for the spike protein of SARS-CoV<ref name="fan">PMID: 32681106</ref> and mouse hepatitis virus<ref name="walls">PMID: 29073020</ref>, among others. These rearrangements also have much in common with the membrane fusion mechansism of influenza hemagglutinin<ref name="hamilton" /><ref name="pabis">PMID: 32188780</ref>. The molecular scenes in this article are based on the [[cryo-EM]] pre- and post-fusion structures of SARS-CoV-2 spike protein reported July, 2020, by Cai, Zhang and coworkers with the group of Bing Chen<ref name="cai-zhang" />. | SARS-CoV-2 spike protein undergoes a dramatic conformational rearrangement (<scene name='85/857791/Morf-6xr8-6xra-lin-theis-cao/5'>restore initial scene</scene>) that plays a central role in fusing the coronavirus membrane with the host cell membrane<ref name="cai-zhang">PMID: 32694201</ref>. Similar conformational transformations have been observed for the spike protein of SARS-CoV<ref name="fan">PMID: 32681106</ref> and mouse hepatitis virus<ref name="walls">PMID: 29073020</ref>, among others. These rearrangements also have much in common with the membrane fusion mechansism of influenza hemagglutinin<ref name="hamilton" /><ref name="pabis">PMID: 32188780</ref>. The molecular scenes in this article are based on the [[cryo-EM]] pre- and post-fusion structures of SARS-CoV-2 spike protein reported July, 2020, by Cai, Zhang and coworkers with the group of Bing Chen<ref name="cai-zhang" />. | ||
{| width=" | {| width="550" class="wikitable" | ||
|- | |- | ||
|colspan="3"|Click thumbnail images to jump to full sizes with explanations below: | |colspan="3"|Click thumbnail images to jump to full sizes with explanations below: | ||
Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
</imagemap> | </imagemap> | ||
| | | | ||
<imagemap> | |||
Image:Cai-zhang-fig-5a.png|150px | |||
default [[#Spontaneous Fusion Transformation]] | |||
</imagemap> | |||
| rowspan="2"| | |||
<imagemap> | |||
Image:Romeo-graphical-abstract-700px.jpg|150px | |||
default [[#Preventing Fusion with Drugs]] | |||
</imagemap> | |||
|- | |||
| colspan="2" style="text-align:center;"| | |||
<imagemap> | <imagemap> | ||
Image:Pabis-MDS-Fig1AD-Labeled.jpg|250px | Image:Pabis-MDS-Fig1AD-Labeled.jpg|250px | ||
default [[#Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Membrane Fusion]] | default [[#Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Membrane Fusion]] | ||
</imagemap> | </imagemap> | ||
|} | |} | ||
Line 117: | Line 123: | ||
:(2) The virus membrane is attached near the <font color="red">'''red balls'''</font>. The <scene name='85/857791/Morf-6xr8-6xra-lin-theis-cao/7'>virus membrane appears to be pulled into close proximity to the host cell membrane</scene> (near the <font color="#0060ff">'''blue balls'''</font>), initiating membrane fusion. The virus membrane is brought closer than shown here: these models lack the stem. The <font color="red">'''red balls'''</font> would actually end up much closer to the <font color="#0060ff">'''blue balls'''</font> than these models show. | :(2) The virus membrane is attached near the <font color="red">'''red balls'''</font>. The <scene name='85/857791/Morf-6xr8-6xra-lin-theis-cao/7'>virus membrane appears to be pulled into close proximity to the host cell membrane</scene> (near the <font color="#0060ff">'''blue balls'''</font>), initiating membrane fusion. The virus membrane is brought closer than shown here: these models lack the stem. The <font color="red">'''red balls'''</font> would actually end up much closer to the <font color="#0060ff">'''blue balls'''</font> than these models show. | ||
<center><i>Use the '''toggle animation''' button to restart animation as needed.<br> | <center><i>Use the '''toggle animation''' button above to restart animation as needed.<br> | ||
Remember that a [[morph]] is intended to help you compare two structures. This morph does NOT portray a realistic transition pathway.</i></center> | Remember that a [[morph]] is intended to help you compare two structures. This morph does NOT portray a realistic transition pathway.</i></center> | ||
:(3) The <scene name='85/857791/Morf-6xr8-6xra-lin-theis-cao/8'>middle portion of the spike protein remains relatively stable</scene>. | :(3) The <scene name='85/857791/Morf-6xr8-6xra-lin-theis-cao/8'>middle portion of the spike protein remains relatively stable</scene>. | ||
An <jmol> | |||
<jmolLink> | |||
<script>load /images/0/09/Spike_SARS_CoV_2_storymorph.pdb; script /scripts/85/857791/Alternate_morph/1.spt; | |||
model 0; select protein and not (912,1162); backbone only; select all; backbone 0.8; | |||
select 912,1162; spacefill 4.0; | |||
anim on</script> | |||
<text>alternate pathway</text> | |||
</jmolLink> | |||
</jmol> <ref>The [[Jmol/Storymorph|Storymorph Jmol scripts]] were used to create the interpolation shown in the morph. [https://proteopedia.org/wiki/index.php/Image:Spike_SARS_CoV_2_storymorph.pdb|Coordinates] available on Proteopedia</ref> between the two conformations shows how some secondary structure is retained while structural elements change orientation and position substantially. USe the button above to start and pause the morph. | |||
<jmol> | |||
<jmolRadioGroup> | |||
<item> | |||
<script>model 0; select not (912, 1162); backbone only; backbone 0.8; model 1; anim on</script> | |||
<text>Lines</text> | |||
<checked>true</checked> | |||
</item> | |||
<item> | |||
<script>model 0; select not (912, 1162); spacefill only; spacefill 4.0; model 1; anim on</script> | |||
<text>Spheres</text> | |||
<checked>false</checked> | |||
</item> | |||
</jmolRadioGroup> | |||
</jmol> | |||
===Membrane Fusion Schematic=== | ===Membrane Fusion Schematic=== | ||
Line 130: | Line 160: | ||
[[Image:Fusion-schematic-hamilton-2012-mod1.png|700px]] | [[Image:Fusion-schematic-hamilton-2012-mod1.png|700px]] | ||
</td></tr><tr><td><b> | </td></tr><tr><td><b> | ||
Figure 1: | |||
<font color="gray">Lipid Bilayers</font>. | <font color="gray">Lipid Bilayers</font>. | ||
<font color="green">Receptor (ACE2 for SARS-CoV-2)</font>. | <font color="green">Receptor (ACE2 for SARS-CoV-2)</font>. | ||
Line 140: | Line 171: | ||
===Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Membrane Fusion=== | ===Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Membrane Fusion=== | ||
Molecular dynamics simulations are consistent with this hypothesis. Below is shown a liposome containing influenza hemagglutinin fusing with a lipid bilayer in a molecular dynamics simulation<ref name="pabis" />. | [[Molecular dynamics simulations]] are consistent with this hypothesis. Below is shown a liposome containing influenza hemagglutinin fusing with a lipid bilayer in a molecular dynamics simulation<ref name="pabis" />. | ||
<table style="border-collapse:collapse;border:1px solid black;width:700px;"><tr><td> | <table style="border-collapse:collapse;border:1px solid black;width:700px;"><tr><td> | ||
[[Image:Pabis-MDS-Fig1AD-Labeled.jpg|700px]] | [[Image:Pabis-MDS-Fig1AD-Labeled.jpg|700px]] | ||
</td></tr><tr><td> | </td></tr><tr><td> | ||
Figure 2: | |||
Results of a molecular dynamics simulation. Note the fusion peptides embedded in the lipid bilayer at left (green). Adapted from Fig. 1 by Pabis, Rawle and Kasson<ref name="pabis" />. Redistribution for non-commercial, educational purposes permitted under the [https://www.pnas.org/authors/fees-and-licenses PNAS License]. Appropriate use confirmed by Peter Kasson, August 8, 2020. | Results of a molecular dynamics simulation. Note the fusion peptides embedded in the lipid bilayer at left (green). Adapted from Fig. 1 by Pabis, Rawle and Kasson<ref name="pabis" />. Redistribution for non-commercial, educational purposes permitted under the [https://www.pnas.org/authors/fees-and-licenses PNAS License]. Appropriate use confirmed by Peter Kasson, August 8, 2020. | ||
</td></tr></table> | </td></tr></table> | ||
Line 156: | Line 188: | ||
[[Image:Cai-zhang-fig-5a.png|350px]] | [[Image:Cai-zhang-fig-5a.png|350px]] | ||
</td></tr><tr><td> | </td></tr><tr><td> | ||
Figure 3: Virion with mixture of pre- and post-fusion spike protein conformations, in the absence of ACE2. | |||
Fig. 5A (cropped) from Cai, Zhang and coworkers<ref name="cai-zhang" /> reproduced in accord with the [https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International] license specified in ''Science''. Permission also given by Bing Chen, August 7, 2020. | Fig. 5A (cropped) from Cai, Zhang and coworkers<ref name="cai-zhang" /> reproduced in accord with the [https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International] license specified in ''Science''. Permission also given by Bing Chen, August 7, 2020. | ||
</td></tr></table> | </td></tr></table> | ||
Line 164: | Line 197: | ||
==Preventing Fusion with Drugs== | ==Preventing Fusion with Drugs== | ||
<table style="border-collapse:collapse;border:1px solid black;margin:0px 0px 6px 6px;float:right;width:350px;"><tr><td> | |||
[[Image:Romeo-graphical-abstract-700px.jpg|350px]] | |||
</td></tr><tr><td> | |||
Figure 4: | |||
Graphical Abstract from Romeo, Iacovelli & Falconi<ref name="romeo" /> reproduced in accord with the COVID-19 pandemic license of Elsevier<ref name="elsevier">This quote is from the PubMedCentral version of the Romeo paper, after you click ''License Information'': "Since January 2020 Elsevier has created a COVID-19 resource centre with free information in English and Mandarin on the novel coronavirus COVID-19. The COVID-19 resource centre is hosted on Elsevier Connect, the company's public news and information website. Elsevier hereby grants permission to make all its COVID-19-related research that is available on the COVID-19 resource centre - including this research content - immediately available in PubMed Central and other publicly funded repositories, such as the WHO COVID database with rights for unrestricted research re-use and analyses in any form or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are granted for free by Elsevier for as long as the COVID-19 resource centre remains active."</ref>. Permission also given by Mattia Falconi, August 12, 2020. | |||
</td></tr></table> | |||
SARS-CoV-2 spike protein has two interior cavities: (i) <scene name='85/857791/6zgi_translucent_backbone/2'>Show spike protein structure</scene> ([[6zgi]]) and then (ii) | SARS-CoV-2 spike protein has two interior cavities: (i) <scene name='85/857791/6zgi_translucent_backbone/2'>Show spike protein structure</scene> ([[6zgi]]) and then (ii) | ||
<jmol> | <jmol> | ||
Line 192: | Line 232: | ||
'''[http://proteopedia.org/wiki/images/6/67/Spike_protein_fusion_mainchain_morph_from_Proteopedia.Org.gif Download] (right click, save link as)''' 500 px wide main chain animation. This shows a smoothed main chain (backbone) trace. Please credit '''Proteopedia.Org''' in accord with our [[Proteopedia:Terms of Service|license]], and '''Cai, Zhang and coworkers<ref name="cai-zhang" />''' for their cryo-EM structures.<br> | '''[http://proteopedia.org/wiki/images/6/67/Spike_protein_fusion_mainchain_morph_from_Proteopedia.Org.gif Download] (right click, save link as)''' 500 px wide main chain animation. This shows a smoothed main chain (backbone) trace. Please credit '''Proteopedia.Org''' in accord with our [[Proteopedia:Terms of Service|license]], and '''Cai, Zhang and coworkers<ref name="cai-zhang" />''' for their cryo-EM structures.<br> | ||
[[Image:Spike protein fusion mainchain morph from Proteopedia.Org.gif]] | [[Image:Spike protein fusion mainchain morph from Proteopedia.Org.gif]] | ||
===Alternate Pathway for Transformation=== | |||
Given that a [[morph]] is intended to help you compare two structures and does not portray a realistic transition pathway, there are many pathways we can imagine. Below is another one that has structural elements swing away from the core structure in a hinge motion as they change conformation. Another choice in this morph is to have different timings for the distinct changes to be able to follow them one at a time. | |||
In the morph at full resolution, you can see a large cavity disappearing, the beta sheets acquiring an additional strand from a different subunit (subunits shown in green, blue and red tints), and changes in the core helix bundle along with the formation of the coiled-coil protrusion made of three helices. | |||
'''[https://proteopedia.org/wiki/images/e/ef/Spike_storymorph.gif Download] (right click, save link as)''' 720 px wide main chain animation. This shows a smoothed main chain (backbone) trace. Please credit '''Proteopedia.Org''' in accord with our [[Proteopedia:Terms of Service|license]], and '''Cai, Zhang and coworkers<ref name="cai-zhang" />''' for their cryo-EM structures.<br> | |||
[[Image:Spike labeled small.gif]] | |||
'''[https://proteopedia.org/wiki/images/3/34/Spike_labeled_spacefill.gif Download] (right click, save link as)''' 720 px wide main chain animation. This shows C-alpha atoms as large spheres. Please credit '''Proteopedia.Org''' in accord with our [[Proteopedia:Terms of Service|license]], and '''Cai, Zhang and coworkers<ref name="cai-zhang" />''' for their cryo-EM structures.<br> | |||
[[Image:Spike labeled spacefill small.gif]] | |||
===Pre-Fusion Spike Protein=== | ===Pre-Fusion Spike Protein=== | ||
Line 209: | Line 261: | ||
==See Also== | ==See Also== | ||
*[[SARS-CoV-2 spike protein priming by furin]] - the step prior to membrane fusion. | *[[SARS-CoV-2 spike protein priming by furin]] - the step prior to membrane fusion. | ||
*[[SARS-CoV-2 spike protein mutations]] suspected to increase transmission rates. | |||
*[[SARS-CoV-2 protein S]] | *[[SARS-CoV-2 protein S]] | ||
*[[Spike protein]] | *[[Spike protein]] | ||
*[[Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)]] | *[[Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)]] | ||
*[[User:Andre Wu Le Chun/Sandbox 1|Prefusion 2019-nCoV spike glycoprotein with a single receptor-binding domain up]] about [[6vsb]] | *[[User:Andre Wu Le Chun/Sandbox 1|Prefusion 2019-nCoV spike glycoprotein with a single receptor-binding domain up]] about [[6vsb]] | ||
*[[Jmol/Cavities pockets and tunnels]] | |||
*[[Cavity programs]] | |||
==Methods== | ==Methods== | ||
===Morphing=== | |||
The pre-fusion structure [[6xr8]] was [[morph|morphed]] to the post-fusion structure [[6xra]] by linear interpolation, requesting 14 intermediate frames (16 total), using the [[Morphs#Linear_Morph_Server|server provided by Karsten Theis]] after another method<ref>Proteopedia's PyMOL morph server was used in both RigiMOL and linear modes, all atoms or only alpha carbon atoms. Rendering these as backbones or traces by Jmol gave broken lines. The reason for backbone breaking was not investigated further.</ref> gave unsatisfactory results. To avoid artifactual movement in the morph, prior to morphing, two changes were required in 6xra: (i) the names of chains B and C needed to be swapped (done with SwissPDBViewer), and (ii) the structure needed to be rotated +120° around the Z axis (Jmol "rotateselected" command). The morph was an 11 MB file, which took 25 sec to load into JSmol. Each script took a minimum of 8 sec to complete. To reduce both the bulk of this file and the processing times for JSmol, the alpha carbons were extracted (along with the MODEL and ENDMDL records) by deleting all other lines in the PDB file<ref name="cao">Selecting *.ca in the [[Jmol/Application|Jmol Java application]] and saving a PDB file produced a PDB file with numerous errors. The desired result was obtained with this command in macOS Terminal: <tt>sed -e /REMARK/d -e /HETATM/d -e /^ATOM\ \ [\ 0-9][0-9][0-9][0-9][0-9]\ \ [CONS][\ B-Z].*$/d <original.pdb >product.pdb</tt>.</ref>. The resulting 16 model morph PDB file is [[Image:Morf-6xr8-6xra-theis-cao.pdb]]. | The pre-fusion structure [[6xr8]] was [[morph|morphed]] to the post-fusion structure [[6xra]] by linear interpolation, requesting 14 intermediate frames (16 total), using the [[Morphs#Linear_Morph_Server|server provided by Karsten Theis]] after another method<ref>Proteopedia's PyMOL morph server was used in both RigiMOL and linear modes, all atoms or only alpha carbon atoms. Rendering these as backbones or traces by Jmol gave broken lines. The reason for backbone breaking was not investigated further.</ref> gave unsatisfactory results. To avoid artifactual movement in the morph, prior to morphing, two changes were required in 6xra: (i) the names of chains B and C needed to be swapped (done with SwissPDBViewer), and (ii) the structure needed to be rotated +120° around the Z axis (Jmol "rotateselected" command). The morph was an 11 MB file, which took 25 sec to load into JSmol. Each script took a minimum of 8 sec to complete. To reduce both the bulk of this file and the processing times for JSmol, the alpha carbons were extracted (along with the MODEL and ENDMDL records) by deleting all other lines in the PDB file<ref name="cao">Selecting *.ca in the [[Jmol/Application|Jmol Java application]] and saving a PDB file produced a PDB file with numerous errors. The desired result was obtained with this command in macOS Terminal: <tt>sed -e /REMARK/d -e /HETATM/d -e /^ATOM\ \ [\ 0-9][0-9][0-9][0-9][0-9]\ \ [CONS][\ B-Z].*$/d <original.pdb >product.pdb</tt>.</ref>. The resulting 16 model morph PDB file is [[Image:Morf-6xr8-6xra-theis-cao.pdb]]. | ||
===Interior Cavities=== | |||
[[6zgi]] was loaded into the [[Jmol/Application|Jmol Java application]] (~11-fold faster than [[JSmol]]), and rendered as translucent backbone, each chain a different pastel color. The command | |||
:<tt>isosurface minset 100 interior cavity 3.0 10.0</tt> | |||
was executed (~45 sec). The numeric parameters in that command were determined by trial and error (see [[Jmol/Cavities pockets and tunnels]]). The cavity surface data were saved as Jmol voxel data, and uploaded to Proteopedia as [[Image:6zgi-cavities.jvxl]]. The button above reads that file, rather than re-calculating the cavities, in order to display the interior cavity surface data much more quickly. See also [[Jmol/Cavities pockets and tunnels]]. | |||
==Acknowledgement== | |||
Eric Martz thanks Deborah Spitz for a critique that improved this article. | |||
== References and Notes == | == References and Notes == | ||
<references/> | <references/> |