Sandbox Reserved 712: Difference between revisions
(28 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
== '''Description''' == | == '''Description''' == | ||
<scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/3ggu/1'>3ggu</scene> is a drug resistant HIV protease. Shown is a patient's variant in complex with [[darunavir]]. | <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/3ggu/1'>3ggu</scene> is a drug resistant [[HIV-1 protease]]. Shown is a patient's variant in complex with [[darunavir]]. | ||
HIV proteases (PR) are essential for the functioning of the retrovirus that causes AIDS. HIV needs active proteases to process gag & gap - polymerase polyprotein precursors into mature structural proteins and replicative enzymes. | |||
HIV | [[HIV-1 protease]]s contain a highly conserved region Asp - Thr - Gly (<scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Activesiteasp25/1'>Asp25</scene>, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Activesitethr26/1'>Thr26</scene> and | ||
<scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Activesitegly27/2'>Gly27</scene>), with the aspartic residue being the <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Activesite/2'>active site</scene> | <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Activesitegly27/2'>Gly27</scene>), with the aspartic residue being the <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Activesite/2'>active site</scene> | ||
in the aspartyl protease.<ref> PMID:3290901 </ref> | in the aspartyl protease.<ref> PMID:3290901 </ref> | ||
Because of its importance for the life-cycle of the retrovirus, HIV- | Because of its importance for the life-cycle of the retrovirus, [[HIV-1 protease]]s are the major target for anti-HIV treatment. | ||
HIV protease inhibitors are the most potent agents used in anti-HIV treatment. However it appears that HIV-PRs develop a resistance to the inhibitor. <ref> PMID:12543689 </ref> | HIV protease inhibitors are the most potent agents used in anti-HIV treatment. However it appears that HIV-PRs develop a resistance to the inhibitor. <ref> PMID:12543689 </ref> | ||
3ggu (also PR<sub>DRV5</sub>) is a mutated clinically derived PR that shows phenotypical resistance to darunavir. Darunavir is a human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) protease (PR) inhibitor (PI) which has inhibiting effects on many HIV type 1 PR variants that show resistance to earlier-generation-PIs. <ref name="Molecular"> PMID:19535439 </ref> | 3ggu (also PR<sub>DRV5</sub>) is a mutated clinically derived PR that shows phenotypical resistance to darunavir. [[Darunavir]] is a human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) protease (PR) inhibitor (PI) which has inhibiting effects on many HIV type 1 PR variants that show resistance to earlier-generation-PIs. <ref name="Molecular"> PMID:19535439 </ref> | ||
== '''Darunavir: HIV-Protease Inhibitor''' == | == '''Darunavir: HIV-Protease Inhibitor''' == | ||
Darunavir (also known as TMC114) is a HIV-PR Inhibitor | [[Darunavir]] (also known as TMC114) is a HIV-PR Inhibitor. The wild-type HIV as well as a large panel of PI-resistant recombinant viruses derived from clinical samples show high susceptibility to [[darunavir]]. <ref> PMID:15917527 </ref> | ||
One reason for the high potency of darunavir is the strong binding of the PI to the main-chains of the protease active-site amino acids. <ref> PMID:14506019 </ref> A second reason might be the ability of the PI to fit closely into the substrate envelope. <ref>PMID:15479840</ref> | One reason for the high potency of [[darunavir]] is the strong binding of the PI to the main-chains of the protease active-site amino acids. <ref> PMID:14506019 </ref> A second reason might be the ability of the PI to fit closely into the substrate envelope. <ref>PMID:15479840</ref> | ||
Darunavir shows a high genetical barrier to resistance development. In fact studies indicate that the development of resistance needs more specific mutations and develops more slowly. <ref> PMID:15917527 </ref> | [[Darunavir]] shows a high genetical barrier to resistance development. In fact studies indicate that the development of resistance needs more specific mutations and develops more slowly. <ref> PMID:15917527 </ref> | ||
Darunavir resistance-associated mutations are V11I, V32I, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L33f/1'>L33F</scene>, I47V, I50V, I54L, I54M, G73S, L76V, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/I84v/2'>I84V</scene> and | [[Darunavir]] resistance-associated mutations are V11I, V32I, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L33f/1'>L33F</scene>, I47V, I50V, I54L, I54M, G73S, L76V, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/I84v/2'>I84V</scene> and | ||
<scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L89v/1'>L89V</scene> ([[HIV Protease Resistance]]). Those mutations occurred in patients who have a high number of PI resistance-associated mutations. <ref> PMID:17416261 </ref> | <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L89v/1'>L89V</scene> ([[HIV Protease Resistance]]). Those mutations occurred in patients who have a high number of PI resistance-associated mutations. <ref> PMID:17416261 </ref> | ||
== '''Structure''' == | == '''Structure''' == | ||
Line 50: | Line 31: | ||
[[HIV-1 protease]]s are essential for HIV to survive. They are small enzymes, which are made out of two identical, 99 amino acids long, protein chains. | [[HIV-1 protease]]s are essential for HIV to survive. They are small enzymes, which are made out of two identical, 99 amino acids long, protein chains. | ||
These chains form a tunnel, which is covered by so called (flexible) "flaps". The flaps's function is to "wrap around" the substrate-protein and holding it close to the tunnel and therefore to the active site. | These chains form a tunnel, which is covered by so called (flexible) "flaps". The flaps's function is to "wrap around" the substrate-protein and holding it close to the tunnel and therefore to the active site. | ||
The <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Activesite/2'>active site</scene> is located in the tunnel. The <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Activesite/2'>active site</scene> uses water molecules to break the subrate-protein chain. | The <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Activesite/2'>active site</scene> is located in the tunnel. The <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Activesite/2'>active site</scene> uses water molecules to break the subrate-protein chain. Its most important residues are two aspartate amino acids. | ||
Inhibitors occupy similar positions as the natural substrate-protein chains. | |||
<ref>HIV-1 Protease, June 2000 Molecule of the Month by David Goodsell [http://dx.doi.org/10.2210/rcsb_pdb/mom_2000_6 DOI: 10.2210/rcsb_pdb/mom_2000_6]</ref> | <ref>HIV-1 Protease, June 2000 Molecule of the Month by David Goodsell [http://dx.doi.org/10.2210/rcsb_pdb/mom_2000_6 DOI: 10.2210/rcsb_pdb/mom_2000_6]</ref> | ||
=== X-ray structure analysis of 3ggu === | === X-ray structure analysis of 3ggu === | ||
[[Image:Positions_of_the_mutations_in_PR_variants_used_for_structural_studies.jpg|left|320px|thumb| Fig. | [[Image:Positions_of_the_mutations_in_PR_variants_used_for_structural_studies.jpg|left|320px|thumb| Fig.1 Positions of the mutations in PR variants used for structural studies. <ref name="Molecular" />]] | ||
[[Image: Structural_changes_in_PRdrv5_mutant.jpg|right|200px|thumb| Fig. | [[Image: Structural_changes_in_PRdrv5_mutant.jpg|right|200px|thumb| Fig.2 Structural changes in PR<sub>DRV5</sub> mutant relative to wild-type PR. <ref name="Molecular" />]] | ||
[[Image: Detailed_view_of_darunavir-enzyme_interactions.jpg|right|200px|thumb| Fig. | [[Image: Detailed_view_of_darunavir-enzyme_interactions.jpg|right|200px|thumb| Fig.3 Detailed view of the darunavir-enzyme interactions. <ref name="Molecular" />]] | ||
The crystal structure was determined in complex with darunavir with 1.8-Å resolutions. The crystal is formed out of one PR dimer in the asymmetric unit with two inhibitor molecules bound in alternative orientations. | The crystal structure was determined in complex with [[darunavir]] with 1.8-Å resolutions. The crystal is formed out of one PR dimer in the asymmetric unit with two inhibitor molecules bound in alternative orientations. | ||
Surface residues <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/R45/1'>R45</scene> and <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/R55/1'>R55</scene> have disordered side chains, but the other amino acid residue changes could be modeled into well-defined electron density maps. | Surface residues <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/R45/1'>R45</scene> and <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/R55/1'>R55</scene> have disordered side chains, but the other amino acid residue changes could be modeled into well-defined electron density maps. | ||
PR<sub>DRV5</sub> contains darunavir mutations <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/V82t/1'>V82T</scene> and | PR<sub>DRV5</sub> contains darunavir mutations <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/V82t/1'>V82T</scene> and | ||
<scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/I84v/2'>I84V</scene> (see Fig. | <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/I84v/2'>I84V</scene> (see Fig.1, Part B, indicated in bold print) that are directly involved in substrate-darunavir-interactions (change of S2/S2' subsites). | ||
The other 18 mutations are outside the binding cleft, but some are still in direct contact with the binding residues (e.g. <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L10i/1'>L10I</scene>, K20M, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L33f/1'>L33F</scene>, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/I54v/1'>I54L/V</scene> and <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L90m/1'>L90M</scene>). | The other 18 mutations are outside the binding cleft, but some are still in direct contact with the binding residues (e.g. <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L10i/1'>L10I</scene>, K20M, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L33f/1'>L33F</scene>, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/I54v/1'>I54L/V</scene> and <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L90m/1'>L90M</scene>). | ||
Line 70: | Line 50: | ||
<scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Mutations_flap/1'>Mutations</scene> <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L33f/1'>L33F</scene>, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/M36l/1'>M36L</scene>, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/N37t/1'>N37T</scene>, | <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/Mutations_flap/1'>Mutations</scene> <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L33f/1'>L33F</scene>, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/M36l/1'>M36L</scene>, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/N37t/1'>N37T</scene>, | ||
<scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/P39s/1'>P39S</scene>, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/K45r/1'>K45R</scene>, M46I, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/I54v/1'>I54V</scene> and <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/K55r/1'>K55R</scene> cause structural changes in the flap region and the flap hinge. | <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/P39s/1'>P39S</scene>, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/K45r/1'>K45R</scene>, M46I, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/I54v/1'>I54V</scene> and <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/K55r/1'>K55R</scene> cause structural changes in the flap region and the flap hinge. | ||
The pictures on the right (Fig. | The pictures on the right (Fig.2 and Fig.3) show the regions (indicated in blue) that undergo structural changes caused by the mutations. | ||
To see the full images, with changes in PR<sub>DRV1</sub> and comparative structure of wild-type, PR<sub>DRV1</sub> and PR<sub>DRV5</sub> follow the links: | To see the full images, with changes in PR<sub>DRV1</sub> and comparative structure of wild-type, PR<sub>DRV1</sub> and PR<sub>DRV5</sub> follow the links: | ||
[http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2738195/figure/f4/ Structural changes in PR<sub>DRV</sub> mutants relative to wild-type PR] and | [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2738195/figure/f4/ Structural changes in PR<sub>DRV</sub> mutants relative to wild-type PR] and | ||
Line 76: | Line 56: | ||
It was discovered that the inhibitor substituents can adjust their positions depending on changes of the substrate binding pockets. Among them the P2' aminophenyl moiety undergoes the biggest changes. <ref name="Molecular" /> | It was discovered that the inhibitor substituents can adjust their positions depending on changes of the substrate binding pockets. Among them the P2' aminophenyl moiety undergoes the biggest changes. <ref name="Molecular" /> | ||
== '''Phenotypic susceptibility and enzymatic analysis''' == | |||
Samples PR<sub>DRV1</sub> to PR<sub>DRV6</sub> have been cloned and expressed in ''E. coli'', purified and characterized in vitro by monitoring cleavage of a chromogenic peptide substrate in the presence and absence of specific PIs. | |||
PR<sub>DRV5</sub> (<scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/3ggu/1'>3ggu</scene>) shows twenty mutated amino acids. The PR mutations that are associated to the darunavir resistance ([[HIV Protease Resistance]]) are <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L33f/1'>L33F</scene>, <scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/I84v/2'>I84V</scene> and | |||
<scene name='Sandbox_Reserved_712/L89v/1'>L89V</scene>. | |||
These mutations lead to a change in the susceptibility to the PI. In the case of 3ggu we observe a 32-fold susceptibility to [[darunavir]]. In comparison to [[amprenavir]], which is a structural related PI of [[darunavir]], it only shows a 24-fold susceptibility. The key-mutations that are responsible for the darunavir resistance are V32I, I54L and I54M. Those were not found in PR<sub>DRV5</sub> which explains the smaller phenotypic changes in the susceptibility to [[darunavir]]. (Complete Table: [http://jvi.asm.org.scd-rproxy.u-strasbg.fr/content/83/17/8810/T4.expansion.html/ Genotypes and phenotype changes analyzed with recombinant virus assay]) Nevertheless, determining the inhibition constants by kinetic analysis using a chromogenic peptide substrate and the appropriate inhibitor, we can observe an increase of the K<sub>i</sub> value for all the samples in comparison to the wild-type virus. PR<sub>DRV5</sub> - which only has a specific activity of 5% of the wild-type value - also shows a smaller difference in k<sub>i</sub> value for [[darunavir]] in comparison to the other used samples. (Complete Table: [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2738195/table/t6/ K<sub>i</sub> values for the inhibitors of PR mutants]) <ref name="Molecular"> PMID:19535439 </ref> | |||
[[Image:Relative_vitality_values_for_recombinant_PRs_and_PRIs.jpg | thumb | 220px | left | Fig.4 Relative vitality values. <ref name="Molecular"/>]] | |||
The relative vitality values are defined as v = (K<sub>i</sub>k<sub>cat</sub>/K<sub>m</sub>)<sub>MUT</sub>/(K<sub>i</sub>k<sub>cat</sub>/K<sub>m</sub>)<sub>WT</sub>. It describes the relative ability of a PR species to hydrolyze its substrate when the inhibitor is present. This means the higher the vitality the more does the mutated PR support the viral replication. <ref name="Kinetic"> PMID:7626598 </ref> | |||
The relative vitality is related to the phenotypic changes in the susceptibility to [[darunavir]]. As one can see in the diagram, the more darunavir-associated mutations there are, the higher is the relative vitality (PR<sub>DRV4</sub> > PR<sub>DRV1</sub> > PR<sub>DRV2</sub> > PR<sub>DRV6</sub>). Due to the fact that PR<sub>DRV5</sub> does not have the key mutations, it has a low vitality value for [[darunavir]] and the structural related [[amprenavir]] in comparison to the other samples. The [[lopinavir]] pattern looks different than the overall pattern of [[darunavir]] and [[amprenavir]], because it has a different structure and resistance profile than the others.(Fig.4) <ref name="Molecular"> PMID:19535439 </ref> | |||
Despite the many mutations the k<sub>cat</sub> values were still between 30% and 50% of the wild-type value. In contrast the K<sub>m</sub> values of the mutants were (mostly) four- to eightfold higher than the wild-type PR. | |||
(Complete Table: [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2738195/table/t5/ Enzyme characteristics of PR variants analyzed in this study]) <ref name="Molecular" /> | |||
== '''Applications''' == | == '''Applications''' == | ||
HIV (human immunodeficiency virus) which causes AIDS (Acquired immunodeficiency syndrome) is one of the most threating viruses today. | HIV (human immunodeficiency virus) which causes AIDS (Acquired immunodeficiency syndrome) is one of the most threating viruses today. | ||
The high mutation rate of the virus leads to the fast development of drug resistance. The phenotypic characterization, enzyme kinetics and X-ray structural analysis of recombinant viruses | The high mutation rate of the virus leads to the fast development of drug resistance. The phenotypic characterization, enzyme kinetics and X-ray structural analysis of recombinant viruses offer a way to get a better understanding of the drug resistance.<ref name="Molecular" /> The knowledge we gain through that kind of experiments could help to develop new drugs for HIV-positive patients in the future. | ||
== '''External Resources''' == | == '''External Resources''' == |